Re:
|
Chanticleer
Holdings, Inc. (the “Company”)
Form
10-K for the year ended December 31, 2008
File
Number 814-00709
|
1.
|
Please
expand the disclosure in the second paragraph to state whether the CEO has
made a firm commitment to make loans to you in the amount of
$50,000. If so, disclose the expected repayment terms of the
loans, including the rate of interest. To the extent, such
'loans' will instead be in the form of 'advances,' which have no specific
repayment terms please clarify. In addition, expand the last
paragraph to clarify from whom (or which investment) such distribution in
the amount of $1,275,000 will be received, and explain the circumstances
for the distribution and whether it is represents a cash-out of a portion
of or of your entire investment. It is unclear from your
disclosures as how or where such large distribution will be
generated. Finally, disclose that you have borrowed the full
amount of $500,000 line of credit, and that such credit line expires in
June 2009, and indicated whether you anticipate renewal of the credit
line.
|
2.
|
Please
expand to disclose how you determined the fair value of the securities
received (i.e., the amount to recognize as revenue) in exchange for the
services you provided for each year presented. In this regard,
your disclosure should address how you determined the measurement date and
the value to assign to the securities received and whether any of the
terms of the securities are subject to adjustment after the measurement
date. For guidance, see paragraphs 4-6 of EITF
00-8. Your revenue recognition policy in the notes to the
financial statements on page 25 should also be expanded to describe how
the board of directors determines the fair value of the stock
received.
|
3.
|
Expand
the disclosure to discuss from whom the securities have been received and
whether the transactions were with your related party equity investee
Investors LLC. Further, expand to describe the types of
management services you provide and explain why your revenues decreased
during the period.
|
2008
|
2007
|
|||||||
Special
Projects Group
|
$ | - | $ | 39,380 | ||||
Total
non-affiliate
|
- | 39,380 | ||||||
Chanticleer
Investors LLC
|
100,000 | 100,000 | ||||||
Syzygy
Entertainment, Ltd.
|
128,555 | 385,665 | ||||||
Miscellaneous
|
6,202 | 5,500 | ||||||
Total
affiliate
|
$ | 234,757 | $ | 491,165 |
4.
|
Expand
the disclosure under "Asset Impairment" to disclose the impairment
occurred in fiscal year 2008 and quantify the total remaining investment
in your gas well investments at the most recent balance sheet
date. Disclose and tell us supplementally how you are
accounting for the investment in these gas wells (i.e., cost or equity
method investment, marketable securities, other), as it is not clear as to
the nature of these investments or where they are reflected in the balance
sheet. With regard to "Equity in Earnings (Losses) of
Investments," disclose the amount of earnings (losses) for each period
presented and explain in detail the reasons for the significant
changes.
|
5.
|
For
each of these headings please disclose the amounts incurred for each
period as reflected on the statements of
operations.
|
2008
|
2007
|
|||||||
Income
(expense):
|
||||||||
Unrealized
gains (losses) of marketable equity securities
|
$ | 5,000 | $ | (43,000 | ) | |||
Interest
expense
|
(20,486 | ) | (10,933 | ) | ||||
Realized
gains from sale of investments
|
- | 24,696 |
6.
|
We
note the disclosure that your most critical accounting policy is the
valuation of investments. We also note the disclosure in the
second paragraph that (i) your valuation process is intended to provide a
consistent basis for determining the fair value of your available-for-sale
investment, (ii) you will record unrealized loss on investments when you
believe that an investment has become impaired, including where
realization of an equity security is doubtful, and (iii) you record
unrealized gain if you believe that the underlying security has
appreciated in value. Please consider revising the last two
sentences of the second paragraph to conform to the guidance for measuring
and recording the impairment of available-for-sale securities located in
paragraph 16 of SFAS No. 115, paragraphs 7 through 15 of FSP FAS
115-1/124-1, and to SAB Topic 5.M. In this regard,
significantly expand to discuss how you determine whether an individual
investment has been impaired, whether the impairment is other than
temporary, and how you determine the amount of the impairment
loss.
|
·
|
The
length of the time and the extent to which the market value has been less
than the cost;
|
·
|
The
financial condition and near-term prospects of the issuer, including any
specific events which may influence the operations of the issuer such as
changes in technology that may impair the earnings potential of the
investment or the discontinuance of a segment of the business that may
affect the future earnings potential;
or
|
·
|
The
intent and ability of the holder to retain its investment in the issuer
for a period of time sufficient to allow for any anticipated recovery in
market value.
|
7.
|
See
the financing activity line item "Advance from related
party." From disclosure in Note 9, we see that such advance is
non-interest bearing, and does not appear to represent a
loan. In this regard, to the extent the advance was used for
working capital purposes not identified with any type of investing or
financing activity, please reclassify this amount to cash flows used in
operating activities. See SFAS No. 95, paragraph
22. We also note you received additional advances in the first
quarter ended March 31, 2009. Such advances should also be
similarly reclassified, as
appropriate.
|
8.
|
See
the third paragraph. Please clarify how the total 6% interest
earned on the convertible note is "distributed" by Investors LLC, as we
note you indicate one-third of the interest is paid as a management fee to
you while the remaining 4% interest is distributed to you and other
investors on a pro-rata basis. Also, expand the disclosure in
the fourth paragraph of Note 11 to disclose that the $5.0 million, 6%
convertible note is the principle asset of Investors LLC, which you hold a
23% equity investment.
|
9.
|
Please
clarify that your revenue includes management fees, and that you also earn
additional revenue for management and other technical services provided to
certain of your investments (please define the meaning and nature of
'certain of your investments'). Please note that "revenues"
should exclude equity in earnings (losses) of your
investments. Also please expand to indicate your policy for
revenue recognition using the guidance in SAB Topic
13.A.1.
|
·
|
Persuasive
evidence of an arrangement exists;
|
·
|
Delivery
has occurred or services have been
rendered;
|
·
|
The
seller's price to the buyer is fixed or determinable;
and
|
·
|
Collectability
is reasonably assured.
|
10.
|
Please
expand the disclosures of your available-for-sale securities to further
provide the major type of security. In this regard, indicate
the securities that pertain to debt, equity or other security
types. See paragraph 19 of SFAS No. 115. In
addition, for any debt securities, disclose the contractual maturity dates
pursuant to paragraph 20 of SFAS No.
115.
|
Unrecognized
|
||||||||||||
Holding
|
Fair
|
|||||||||||
Cost
|
Losses
|
Value
|
||||||||||
December 31, 2008
|
||||||||||||
Special
Projects Group
|
$ | 144,350 | $ | (112,943 | ) | $ | 31,407 | |||||
Syzygy
Entertainment, Ltd.
|
1,114,221 | (1,037,083 | ) | 77,138 | ||||||||
$ | 1,258,571 | $ | (1,150,026 | ) | $ | 108,545 | ||||||
December 31, 2007
|
||||||||||||
Special
Projects Group
|
$ | 144,350 | $ | (92,005 | ) | $ | 52,345 | |||||
Syzygy
Entertainment, Ltd.
|
1,114,221 | (150,000 | ) | 964,221 | ||||||||
$ | 1,258,571 | $ | (242,005 | ) | $ | 1,016,566 |
11.
|
To
the extent any of your equity method investees are considered significant
pursuant to the investment, asset, and income tests for significant
subsidiary outlined in Rule 1-02(w) of Regulation S-X, substituting 20%
for 10%, please provide summarized financial data for each such investee
(or combined investees that exceed 20% on an aggregated basis) that
includes at a minimum, revenues, gross profit, income (loss) from
continuing operations, and net income (loss). Such data in the
annual financial statement notes should not be labeled as
"unaudited." In this regard, it appears that summarized
financial data may be required for your equity method investee,
Chanticleer Investors, LLC.
|
2008
|
2007
|
|||||||
Revenue
(interest income)
|
$ | 300,000 | $ | 300,000 | ||||
Gross
profit
|
$ | 300,000 | $ | 300,000 | ||||
Income
from continuing operations
|
$ | 199,506 | $ | 199,232 | ||||
Net
income
|
$ | 199,506 | $ | 199,232 |
12.
|
It
appears you inadvertently omitted an evaluation of your disclosure
controls and procedures pursuant to the requirements of Item 307 of
Regulation S-K. We note you have appropriately include such
information in your March 31, 2009 Quarterly Report on Form
10-Q. Please comply in future filings on Form
10-K.
|
13.
|
We
assume that you adopted SFAS 141(R) on January 1, 2009 as
anticipated. If our understanding is correct, it appears that
the deferred acquisition costs should have been charged off as
contemplated by paragraph 59 of the revised statement. Please
revise or advise.
|
14.
|
See
the operating activity line item, "Increase (decrease) in deferred
revenue." Please tell us how the decrease of $72,917 was
computed for the three months ended March 31, 2009, as we note that there
was no amount of deferred revenue recorded on the balance sheet at
December 31, 2008 and such amount was approximately $302,000 at March 31,
2009. In addition, expand the last paragraph of note 3 to
disclose the total value of the two new investments received in exchange
for services provided, and disclose that these investments are accounted
for using the cost method, if true.
|
15.
|
As
a related matter, please quantify your percentage ownership interest in
each of the two companies. In addition, please clarify how
estimated fair market value was determined. If the companies
are not publicly traded, describe each of the companies and explain your
valuation methodology in detail.
|
16.
|
Please
provide us with a supplemental schedule of each individually significant
component of your available-for-sale securities as of each balance sheet
date. Identify each significant investee and describe the
nature of the investment. Explain and illustrate the
methodology you applied in order to ascertain whether each such investment
was other than temporarily impaired at the balance sheet dates and provide
detailed support for you conclusion. We may have further
comments upon review of your
response.
|
Unrecognized
|
||||||||||||
Holding
|
Fair
|
|||||||||||
Cost
|
Losses
|
Value
|
||||||||||
March 31, 2009
|
||||||||||||
Special
Projects Group
|
$ | 144,350 | $ | (112,943 | ) | $ | 31,407 | |||||
Syzygy
Entertainment, Ltd.
|
1,114,221 | (1,037,083 | ) | 77,138 | ||||||||
$ | 1,258,571 | $ | (1,150,026 | ) | $ | 108,545 | ||||||
December 31, 2008
|
||||||||||||
Special
Projects Group
|
$ | 144,350 | $ | (112,943 | ) | $ | 31,407 | |||||
Syzygy
Entertainment, Ltd.
|
1,114,221 | (1,075,652 | ) | 38,569 | ||||||||
$ | 1,258,571 | $ | (1,188,595 | ) | $ | 69,976 |
17.
|
Refer
to your discussion of revenue. Please revise to clarify, if
true, that you earned management fees on services that you provided to
previously unrelated companies. In addition, please state that
these companies compensated you with shares of their stock rather than in
cash. Your current disclosure that you "received equity
investments" is confusing.
|
18.
|
See
the paragraph discussion of "other income (expense)." Please
clarify that in the three months ended March 31, 2008 you recorded an
unrealized holding loss of $17,500 from marketable equity securities, if
true.
|
19.
|
Refer
to the Form 8-K form May 29, 2009. We note that you have agreed
to extend the term of the $5 million loan originally due on May 24,
2009. Please discuss the business reasons for your very recent
decision to extend this loan for an additional eighteen
months. Discuss the consideration you have given to the
collectability of this loan and to the valuation of your related
investment in Chanticleer Investors
LLC.
|
20.
|
In
addition, please explain whether and how this development impacts your
liquidity for the fiscal year.
|
21.
|
Please
expand the disclosure under section (b) to clarify whether or not there
have been any changes in your internal control over financial
reporting. Your current disclosure is limited to the wording
"internal controls." See Item 308T(b) of Regulation
S-K. In addition, please expand to describe the corrective
actions taken with regard to significant deficiencies and material
weaknesses (and describe the material weaknesses identified in your
internal control over financial reporting). In this regard, we
note management's assessment of the internal control over financial
reporting at December 31, 2008 was 'not effective.' Please
explain what corrective measures were implemented to reach the conclusion
that your disclosure controls and procedures are 'effective' subsequently
at March 31, 2009. In addition, please reconsider your
conclusion upon resolution of these
comments.
|
·
|
the
company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in
the filing;
|
·
|
staff
comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not
foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the
filing; and
|
·
|
the
company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding
initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities
laws of the United States.
|